Post Reply
Breathtest
by David_J • Wed 31 May 2017 11:54

Can anybody tell me whether alcohol testing kits are legally required to be carried in cars in France? There is much confusing and conflicting information.

User avatar
David_J
230
Aug 2006
Re: Breathtest
by Dave • Wed 31 May 2017 12:31

According to www.securite-routiere.gouv.fr (and many other sources) the law is still in force but there is no fine. So yes, you legally have to carry an unused alcohol testing kit but the fine for not carrying one (€11) has been suspended indefinitely.

I've never had a kit myself.

User avatar
Dave
Administrator
1432
Aug 2004
Re: Breathtest
by rictel • Wed 31 May 2017 15:35

I got stopped in a routine checkpoint a few weeks ago & no mention was made of a breath kit. I think i did buy one years ago but couldn't say where it is & it's probably passed it's use by date now anyway :lol:

User avatar
rictel
Moderator
221
Dec 2007
Re: Breathtest
by virtdave • Wed 31 May 2017 17:17

This apparently was so breathtakingly (so to speak) silly that it's become like one of the many unenforced laws which continue on the books, and just remain for the amusement they provide. Years ago there was a regular feature in the American Readers' Digest called "There ought to be a law" devoted to bizarre regulations--like, "In Wilmington, Delaware, it's illegal to put pants on a cat."

User avatar
virtdave
1112
Sep 2008
Re: Breathtest
by David_J • Wed 31 May 2017 18:44

Thanks all, that was pretty much what I thought but I thought best to check the current understanding - probably best filed in the "there will be no septic tanks in France" folder.

User avatar
David_J
230
Aug 2006
Re: Breathtest
by RobertArthur • Wed 31 May 2017 21:51

The position of the French government. The ethylotest onboard obligation was introduced March 1 2012, including a penalty of 11 euros. Exactly a year later they skipped this fine with a special decrét, so this wonderful piece of French legislation is still (a little bit) alive, but more than crippled.

What happened? The French government sometimes specialises in the art of drafting "un loi déclaratoire", showing your good will for a just cause. Implementation and other practicalities are less important. The small factory producing these tests could not deliver the vast amounts of tests needed. Officer, I tried twenty shops, but I couldn't buy one single ethylotest. Other problem: measurement reliability. You always hope when using a batch of ten for the same person to get the same readings. Most of them were off target (understatement). Et voila problem two. Where do you store them? In your car. Problem 3: ever opened your car at the end of a hot summer's afternoon? Temperatures of over 55 C inside or even higher. After two weeks of sunshine these ethylotest sets were absolutely useless. I've got two of them, in my glove box, bought them back in 2013. I don't have to bring them to a laboratory to know in what condition they are. But as a law obeying foreign citizen I leave them there and smile when noticing that they still are there, reminding me of the wisdom of politicians.

User avatar
RobertArthur
280
Mar 2009
Re: Breathtest
by Dave • Thu 01 Jun 2017 13:17

... In Wilmington, Delaware, it's illegal to put pants on a cat.
Said virtdave
IMO this is a good law to have and should be extended to dressing up pets in general. :no:

User avatar
Dave
Administrator
1432
Aug 2004
Re: Breathtest
by Creusebear • Thu 01 Jun 2017 22:07

I saw a cockapoo today wearing two red polka dot hair bows - very fetching!

The top ten weirdest laws in Britain today
1. All beached whales and sturgeons must be offered to the Reigning Monarch

2. No person shall, in the course of a business, import into England, potatoes which he knows, or has reasonable cause to suspect, are from Poland

3. It is Illegal to be drunk in the pub

4. It is illegal to carry a plank along a pavement (as well as any ladder, wheel, pole, cask, placard, showboard, or hoop) in the Metropolitan Police District

5. MPs are not allowed to wear armour in Parliament

6. It is an offence to be drunk and in charge of cattle in England and Wales

7. It is illegal to handle a salmon in suspicious circumstances

8. It is an offence to beat or shake any carpet, rug, or mat (except door mats before 8am) in a thoroughfare in the Metropolitan Police District

9. It is illegal to jump the queue in the Tube ticket hall

10. It is illegal to activate your burglar alarm without first nominating a ‘Key-Holder’ who can switch it off in your absence.

Number 7 is my favourite!

User avatar
Creusebear
Moderator
1311
May 2007
Re: Breathtest
by David_J • Fri 02 Jun 2017 10:39

The law mandating London Taxis to carry a bale of straw (for the horse) has been repealed then?

User avatar
David_J
230
Aug 2006
Display topics from previous: Sort by
Your Permissions
  • You cannot post new topics in this forum
  • You cannot reply to topics in this forum
  • You cannot edit your posts in this forum
  • You cannot delete your posts in this forum
  • You cannot post attachments in this forum
Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest

cron